The reason is because middle market retailers are still not using low cost e-procurement tools such as reverse auctions.

There are two primary sources of objections that continue to halt the use of these profit enhancing tools in the middle markets.

The first source is your own buyers or category managers. For some, it is the false belief that these tools will eliminate their jobs. For others, it is the thought that in rising markets, buyers tend to be conservative in the hopes that their suppliers will continue to honor old contracts and delay price increases. Neither assumption is true. E-procurement tools make a buyer’s job easier, as they can do more in less time such as working with dozens of suppliers versus only the same few they have always worked with.  Honoring old contracts almost never happens. Ever-greening of contracts is a huge problem in retail where the lack of sophisticated contract management systems that can provide automatic alerts results in literally thousands of contracts auto renewing annually at predetermined price increases. This results in huge cost increases to retailers that were not planned for. This is all the more reason to be thinking about your spend months before contracts expire even if it only results in cost avoidance.

The second area where you can expect pushback is from your incumbent suppliers or wholesale distributors. If you have never participated in the setup of an RFP or an RFQ (reverse auction) and most middle market retailers have not, that initial call to your suppliers to ask them to participate in a reverse auction event is always an interesting journey. Be prepared for all of the reasons in the world why you should not waste your time on this type of process. The more forceful the pushback the more likely you are to see savings that you should have seen earlier. As such, although suppliers may be well aware of or even using these technologies to reduce their own costs, middle tier retailers have not been able to share in these savings to the extent they deserve to.

If middle market senior executives were to lead the charge and  e-procurement costs as ell as the availability of new sources of supply were no longer an issue, there is absolutely no reason middle market retailers should not benefit greatly from running  e-procurement events such as reverse auctions.

Contact SafeSourcing if you’d like to impact this quarters earnings.

We look forward to and appreciate your comments.

Ron Southard – CEO SafeSourcing

This generally is dependant on their own offerings which can cover the entire procure to pay process? However at it’s most basic, we are talking about e-RFX offerings such as RFI’s, RFP’s and RFQ’s  and other tools and  services that support them. So, the answer to the above is really yes and no.

My typical response to retailers is that spend management  is the management of your company’s spending across all of your operating expenses and SG&A through sophisticated tools that support RFI’s, RFP’s and RFQ’s at a minimum. Organizationally this process should report to a Chief Procurement Officer or the head of your supply chain with strong ties to the finance area. Success is typically measured by a reduction in cost of goods and services or COGS, improvement in quality or both. In retail, spend is represented in for resale products such as general merchandise, gift cards, frozen seafood, meat etc. Spend is also measured in the expense category or not for resale products and services such as supplies, services, technology, real estate etc.

According to Wikipedia, Spend management is the way in which companies control and optimize the money they spend. It involves cutting operating and other costs associated with doing business. These costs typically show up as “operating costs” or SG&A (Selling, General and Administrative) costs, but can also be found in other areas and in other members of the supply chain.

There are dozens of vendors that have a variety of tools and services that are available to assist companies in the analysis and management of their spend for the purpose of present and future decision making. These range from small boutique software houses to giant corporations. Spend management of which e-procurement tools are a part run the gamut from sophisticated contract management applications, reverse auction tools, purchase order management tools and supplier databases etc. In the most sophisticated implementations, these tools may be tightly integrated with retailers enterprise based support systems or data warehouses.

It is not a surprise that many retail companies are not really aware of what their total spend is, or how many suppliers they spend it with. In addition, many retail companies still do not use these tools today. Often times, product specifications are hard to find if documented at all and in some cases the same category might be purchased by different departments across the enterprise without aggregating the spend.

Today’s tools that supports spend management are largely available as internet based or hosted applications that re much lower cost than older in house legacy applications. As such they can be activated almost immediately. This means savings within your present accounting period is possible.

If you’d like to learn more about this process or these types of tools, please contact SafeSourcing. 

We look forward to and appreciate your comments.